The move, which comes a month before Russian President Vladimir Putin’s visit to India, is expected to provoke a major price escalation in the deal, with the Russian side likely to go back to the drawing board and factor in possible costs to the supplier for any probable liability damage.
Sources said India was prepared to restart price negotiations if Russia were to decide in this direction.
Moscow had urged New Delhi to recognise Kudankulam 3 and 4 as being grandfathered under the agreement for Kudankulam 1 and 2, and that the inter-governmental agreement of 2008, which firms up plans for setting up four additional reactors, was done before the liability law.
The Department of Atomic Energy and Nuclear Power Corporation of India Ltd had agreed with the Russian contention and backed the proposal. The Prime Minister’s Office, however, raised questions and sent the matter for detailed legal consideration.
According to reliable sources, the legal view made available to the PMO is that the 2010 civil nuclear liability law would have to apply on any future reactor regardless of any technical argument. No contract, as per the legal view, could be inconsistent with the law.
Based on this, the government has decided against making any exception for Russia, given that DAE is in negotiations with several other prospective reactor suppliers. A waiver, sources said, could also open the government up to the charge of distorting the level playing field.
The India-Russia agreement on Kudankulam 1 and 2 puts the onus of any liability on the operator and does not provide a provision for recourse to the supplier. However, the new liability law does provide for such recourse, and its recently framed rules require this to be reflected in the contract.
Further, informed sources said, the rules and regulations flowing from the liability law have been notified. Officials said they were now technically in force, after having been tabled in Parliament for 30 session days and extendable by another session in case an amendment were to be moved. With no work possible in the monsoon session, a CPM move to initiate amendments lapsed.
However, the parliamentary panel on subordinate legislation did claim that there were inconsistencies between the rules and the Act, particularly in terms of specifying a time period for suppliers to be liable depending on the material in question. Official sources said the recommendations were being examined, but these were not binding on the government.
1.There is no reason to import these when it can be made in India. For so many years Indian nuclear reactors designed and manufactured in India are giving excellent service.2. It is well known fact that western nations are dismantling their old nuclear reactors and wish to offload these to developing nations. it may be or it may not be true for the reactors in this case, but probability is high if they need to go to drafting boards to meet safety requirements to avoid liability.3. One smells strong odour of corruption in nuclear reactors under finalization by this central government based on history of the recent years.
Re:Rule changed: Kudankulam 3 and 4 reactors to come under n-liability law PranabDhalSamanta : New Delhi, Wed Oct 10 2012, 03:41 hrs http://www.indianexpress.com/news/rule-changed-kudankulam-3-and-4-reactors-to-come-under-nliability-law/1014532/0 "a time period for suppliers to be liable depending on the material in question" Precisely this is the reason why every nuclear reactor is an extinction level event AS TIME PASSES. Shut down all nukes. They are infinitely liable for their non utilitarian nature and for violating the right to life. The nuclear wastes including our contaminated bodies are a threat to health and when we die our bodies have to be isolated from the biosphere -quarantined like all the lifeless nuclear wastes. Note that the Health Risks of nuclearisation are infinite compared to the Risk Regulations followed at Kudankulam and all other nukes- the ICRP Recommendations and are null and void and incorporated into Japanese law as ECRR 2010(on line). Scrap nukes globally.